Residents oppose nightly rentals zoning changes in Pat Creek community

The San Juan County Planning Commission meeting held on July 10, 2025, featured significant discussions regarding local zoning regulations and community concerns about nightly rentals. Residents expressed their views on how these issues could impact the character and future of their neighborhoods.

One resident, who has lived in Monticello for three years, voiced skepticism about the town's growth potential, comparing it to larger towns that have expanded due to their locations on interstate freeways. He cautioned against implementing regulations that could harm the community, referencing his experiences in Southern California where policies led to negative outcomes, including the closure of a regional trauma hospital.

Alicia Lafever, a resident of Pack Creek, raised concerns about zoning changes that could allow nightly rentals in her community. She highlighted the importance of maintaining the residential nature of the area, noting that a significant majority of residents oppose such changes. Lafever emphasized the negative impacts she experienced in Moab due to nightly rentals and urged the commission to respect the wishes of the community, which overwhelmingly favors residential zoning.

The meeting underscored the tension between potential development and the desire of residents to preserve the character of their neighborhoods. As discussions continue, the Planning Commission faces the challenge of balancing growth with community values.