Pocatello residents oppose historic firehouse demolition for new housing project

The Pocatello Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on July 9, 2025, highlighted significant community concerns regarding a proposed development in the Alameda neighborhood. Residents voiced strong opposition to plans that would involve demolishing a historic firehouse to make way for new housing units, emphasizing the importance of preserving local history and maintaining the character of their community.

Many speakers, including long-time residents, expressed their deep-rooted connections to the Alameda area, citing its walkability and community resources as vital to their quality of life. Kestrel Hewlett, a resident who grew up in the neighborhood, argued against the proposed development, stating that it would detract from the area's family-friendly atmosphere and historical significance. She emphasized the need for stormwater management solutions rather than dense housing, as flooding is already a concern in the area.

Vonna Newbold, another resident, echoed these sentiments, stating that the proposed housing would be too cramped for the lot size and would disrupt the neighborhood's established character. She and others raised concerns about parking availability, noting that the area already struggles with limited parking due to existing homes and businesses.

Rick Fugger, a local resident with historical ties to the area, urged the commission to reconsider the development, suggesting that it would not only threaten the firehouse but also the peaceful nature of the community. He and others highlighted the potential for increased crime and disturbances that could arise from introducing low-income housing in a predominantly family-oriented neighborhood.

The meeting underscored a collective desire among residents to preserve the historic firehouse and explore alternative uses for the property that would better serve the community's needs. Many called for the city to maintain the building as a historical landmark rather than allowing it to be replaced by new developments that do not align with the neighborhood's character.

As the commission considers the preliminary plat application, the voices of the Alameda residents reflect a broader concern for maintaining the integrity and history of their community while addressing the need for affordable housing in Pocatello. The outcome of this proposal will likely have lasting implications for the neighborhood's future and its residents' quality of life.