In the heart of Lutherville, the Baltimore County Landmarks Preservation Commission convened on July 10, 2025, to discuss a proposal that has stirred both interest and concern among local residents. The meeting, held in a room filled with the soft murmur of community members and officials, focused on the Warren property at 112 McLaughlin Avenue, a historic site dating back to 1877.

The property owners, Daniel Warren and his family, presented plans to construct a detached garage and expand the existing driveway. The proposed garage, measuring 18 by 50 feet, is designed to accommodate the family's vehicles, including a truck and a boat. However, the design has raised eyebrows among neighbors, who worry that its size and flat roof may clash with the aesthetic of the historic district.

Marsha McLaughlin, a neighbor, voiced her concerns during the meeting, describing the garage as resembling a commercial structure rather than a residential addition. She emphasized the importance of maintaining the character of the neighborhood, urging the commission to consider a design that harmonizes with the existing architecture. Her husband, John Alexander, echoed these sentiments, highlighting the potential for increased impervious surfaces that could exacerbate local flooding issues.

The commission members engaged in a thoughtful discussion about the proposal, weighing the need for functionality against the preservation of the district's historical integrity. Staff recommendations suggested that the garage's location and design might need reevaluation to better align with the community's character. They proposed exploring alternative locations or smaller designs that would be less visible and more compatible with the existing structures.

As the meeting progressed, the commission moved to a vote on whether to issue a certificate of appropriateness for the garage. The motion passed, but not without a call for further discussion on how to refine the proposal to better suit the historic context of the area.

The outcome of this meeting leaves the door open for continued dialogue between the Warren family and the commission, as they seek a solution that balances modern needs with the preservation of Lutherville's rich history. As the community watches closely, the hope remains that any new construction will enhance rather than detract from the neighborhood's charm.