Ulster County Legislature Approves Housing Development Project Despite Controversial Past

In a heated session on July 15, 2025, the Ulster County Legislature voted overwhelmingly to transfer a controversial property at 21 Elizabeth Street in Kingston to the Ulster County Housing Development Corporation. The resolution passed with a 23-0 vote, despite significant dissent from some legislators who raised concerns about the property’s troubled history and the decision-making process that led to its acquisition.

Minority Leader David Roberts expressed strong opposition, citing past mistakes in purchasing the property for $700,000, which he deemed a "blatant tear down." He criticized the lack of due diligence, claiming the county had overpaid and failed to properly assess the building's condition before the purchase. Legislator John Maloney echoed these sentiments, calling for an investigation into the decision-making process and questioning the motivations behind the acquisition, suggesting it was politically motivated.

Despite the criticisms, supporters of the resolution, including Legislator Collins, argued that the project represents a crucial step toward addressing the county's housing crisis by providing affordable home ownership opportunities. Collins emphasized the importance of creating generational wealth through home ownership, while other legislators highlighted the potential benefits for the community and the need to move forward despite past errors.

The debate underscored a broader discussion about accountability and transparency in local government, with several legislators calling for a more rigorous examination of past decisions to prevent future missteps. As the county moves forward with this project, the implications for affordable housing in Ulster County remain a focal point of contention among its leaders.