Commissioners Recommend Approval of Peabody Manor Historic Design Guidelines

The Historic Zoning Commission of Nashville convened on July 16, 2025, to discuss the significance of Peabody Manor, a historic apartment building constructed in 1923. The meeting highlighted the architectural contributions of Henry C. Hibbs, who designed the manor and is recognized for his work on several notable Nashville institutions, including Fisk and Vanderbilt universities.

Commission staff presented a recommendation for the approval and adoption of historic landmark design guidelines for Peabody Manor, emphasizing its architectural importance and historical context. Hibbs, who established his practice in Nashville after moving there in 1915, was noted for his mastery of the collegiate gothic style and received multiple AIA gold medals. His influence extended beyond Peabody Manor, with numerous buildings attributed to him across the region.

Ross Edwards, the current owner of Peabody Manor for over two decades, spoke in support of the landmark designation. He reiterated the building's historical significance, noting that at the time of its construction, Nashville had more apartments than any other Southern city except Atlanta. Edwards highlighted the manor's unique features, including its mature trees and innovative amenities, and shared anecdotes about its notable residents, including Lucy Gage, a pioneer in child education.

During the public hearing, commissioners engaged in discussions about the historical context of the building and its architectural significance. One commissioner raised a question regarding the Fisk Library, clarifying the architectural firms involved in its construction. The conversation underscored the commission's role in determining eligibility for historic designation and providing recommendations to the city council, which ultimately makes the final decision.

The meeting concluded with a consensus on the importance of preserving Nashville's architectural heritage, with commissioners expressing appreciation for property owners who seek to protect their historic buildings. The commission will continue to deliberate on the matter before forwarding their recommendations to the council for formal consideration.