Knoxville HCC Reviews Siding Materials for New Construction in Mechanicsville

In a pivotal Knox County government meeting, the debate over siding materials for new construction in historic districts took center stage, highlighting a clash between preservation guidelines and modern building practices. The Historic Zoning Commission (HCC) recommended that new buildings adhere to traditional wood-lapped siding, citing design guidelines that deem synthetic siding inappropriate for new constructions.

Lindsey, a staff member, emphasized the importance of maintaining neighborhood character, noting that the HCC had previously mandated wood-lapped siding for similar projects. The guidelines also call for window materials that align with the historic aesthetic, suggesting wood or aluminum-clad wood, while discouraging the use of slider windows, which do not fit the historic form.

However, applicant R. Bentley Marlowe argued for the acceptance of fiber cement lap siding, citing its approval in other historic districts and support from local heritage organizations. He pointed out that federal guidelines permit its use in federally funded historic preservation projects. Marlowe expressed frustration over the strict siding requirements, stating that if forced to use wood siding, he would abandon the project altogether.

The discussion also touched on the design of chimneys, with recommendations for brick cladding to ensure compatibility with historic structures. Marlowe proposed a faux chimney, arguing that the requirement for a brick structure was impractical and unnecessary.

As the meeting progressed, neighborhood representatives weighed in, with some supporting Marlowe's stance on siding materials. The outcome of this debate could set a significant precedent for future construction in Knox County's historic districts, balancing the need for preservation with the realities of modern building practices. The HCC's final decision will determine the direction of this contentious issue, with implications for both developers and the community at large.