Knoxville Planning Commission Reviews Proposed Home Design on Morgan Street

A proposed single-family home in the historic Fourth and Gill neighborhood of Knoxville has sparked discussions among local officials and residents regarding its design and compatibility with the area’s architectural character. The house, which is set to be built on a vacant lot that has remained undeveloped since the 1980s, is designed as a two-story structure measuring 26 feet wide and 57.5 feet deep. It features a front porch and a hipped roof, but concerns have been raised about its overall aesthetic alignment with neighboring homes.

During a recent government meeting, city staff recommended postponing the application to allow the applicant to address several design issues. Key points of contention include the house's box-like form, which some believe lacks the variety and massing typical of historic buildings in the area. The proposed design has been criticized for its seemingly random window placements and lack of architectural detail, which do not align with the neighborhood's guidelines for new constructions.

The applicant, Zach Taylor, acknowledged the need for revisions, including adjustments to window designs and the addition of more architectural features to enhance the home’s visual appeal. He defended the use of LP Smart Siding, a new product he claims offers durability and aesthetic benefits, although its approval in the historic district remains uncertain.

Community feedback has generally supported the staff's recommendation for postponement, emphasizing the importance of adhering to design guidelines that preserve the neighborhood's historical integrity. Residents expressed concerns that the current proposal does not adequately reflect the character of Fourth and Gill, particularly for a corner lot that historically hosted a more architecturally significant structure.

As discussions continue, the commission will review the applicant's revisions and consider how the proposed home can better fit within the context of the historic neighborhood. The outcome of this proposal will not only impact the immediate area but also set a precedent for future developments in Knoxville's historic districts.