Planning Commission Approves Minor Variance for Historical Properties in Sierra Madre

The Sierra Madre Planning Commission held a regular meeting on July 17, 2025, where key discussions centered around a minor variance for the Meadows at Bailey Canyon and a public hearing for a certificate of appropriateness concerning two historical landmarks: the Richardson House and Lizzie's Trail Inn.

The meeting began with a motion to accept the report on minor variance 25-01 related to the Meadows at Bailey Canyon specific plan. The motion was unanimously approved, allowing the project to move forward.

Following this, the commission reviewed an application for a certificate of appropriateness for the Richardson House, built in 1864, and Lizzie's Trail Inn, constructed in 1900. The proposed renovations for the Richardson House include repairs and replacements of exterior wood siding, windows, and the roof of the enclosed patio. For Lizzie's Trail Inn, the plans involve reroofing and reducing a portion of the front porch due to the growth of a nearby oak tree.

City staff presented details of the proposed materials, including a fire-retardant roofing material for the Richardson House and an asphalt shingle for Lizzie's Trail Inn. The commission discussed the appropriateness of these materials, particularly the roofing for the Richardson House, which some members felt did not fit the historical character of the building.

Public comments were invited, with support expressed for the project from members of the local historical society, who emphasized the importance of preserving these landmarks. However, concerns were raised regarding the visual impact of the proposed roofing materials, prompting a discussion about exploring alternative options that would maintain the historical integrity of the buildings while ensuring durability.

Ultimately, the commission decided to continue the public hearing to allow for further research into alternative roofing materials that could better align with the historical aesthetics of the structures. The next meeting is anticipated to address these concerns and potentially finalize the plans for the renovations.