Advisory Board Votes Unanimously on Fluoride Regulation and Local Control Debate

During the St. Clair County Board of Commissioners meeting on July 17, 2025, a significant discussion emerged regarding the controversial issue of fluoride in drinking water. The meeting highlighted the advisory board's recent decision to prepare a comprehensive report on the pros and cons of fluoride, which will be shared with local communities for further input.

Commissioner and advisory board chairman addressed concerns raised by citizens about a memorandum from Dr. Nevins, which suggested that the health department should implement regulations to remove fluoride from municipal water supplies. However, it was clarified that the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) holds jurisdiction over water supplies, not the county health department. This distinction is crucial as it underscores the limits of local government authority in regulating water quality.

The advisory board unanimously agreed that rather than imposing a mandate, the health department would compile information on fluoride for community review. This approach allows residents to voice their opinions and petition their local governments, which have the final say according to EGLE regulations. The board emphasized the importance of maintaining local control over such decisions, reflecting a commitment to community autonomy.

In addition to the fluoride discussion, the meeting touched on the county's landfill management. Concerns were raised about the reluctance to invest in landfill improvements, with some commissioners advocating for responsible oversight to prevent pollution and ensure that waste management remains a public responsibility. The landfill not only serves as a waste disposal site but also provides recycling and environmental assistance services, making its management a critical issue for the community.

As the advisory board prepares to present its findings on fluoride, the county remains focused on balancing public health concerns with local governance. The outcomes of these discussions will play a vital role in shaping future policies that directly affect the residents of St. Clair County.