Dublin's Historic Buildings Approved for Roof and Door Modifications

In the heart of Dublin, Ohio, the Architectural Review Board convened on July 23, 2025, to discuss significant renovations that honor the city’s rich historical tapestry. The meeting unfolded under the warm glow of city hall lights, where board members and property owners engaged in a spirited dialogue about preserving the architectural integrity of two landmark buildings.

The first item on the agenda was a proposed change in roofing materials for the historic Black Horse Tavern, originally constructed in 1842. The tavern has undergone various transformations over the years, as evidenced by photographs showcasing its evolution from a cedar shake shingle roof in 1879 to a standing seam metal roof in 1982. However, the current roof structure has developed uneven framing, prompting the owners to seek a more suitable roofing solution.

Rick Gerber, one of the property owners, explained that while cedar shake shingles were historically used, modern versions lack the durability of their predecessors, often leading to frequent replacements. The proposed asphalt shingles aim to maintain the building's historical aesthetic while accommodating the uneven surface of the roof. The color choice reflects the original dark hue of the cedar shingles, ensuring a cohesive visual character. The board unanimously approved the application, recognizing its alignment with preservation standards.

The meeting then shifted focus to another landmark building at 48-52 South High Street, where the owners sought approval for door modifications. The proposal included replacing three doors to enhance the building's visual appeal and maintain consistency with previously approved designs. The board noted that the site, which has been part of the National Register of Historic Places since 1979, has seen numerous alterations over the years. The new doors, crafted from aluminum-clad wood, will feature a sleek black shade with neutral trim, further revitalizing the historic facade.

As the evening progressed, the board members expressed their support for both projects, emphasizing the importance of preserving Dublin's architectural heritage while allowing for necessary updates. With the approval of these renovations, Dublin continues to honor its past while adapting to the needs of the present, ensuring that its historical landmarks remain vibrant and relevant for future generations.