Atherton Planning Commission Denies Removal of Healthy Cedar Tree Amid Driveway Plans

The Atherton Planning Commission made significant decisions regarding tree removals during its recent meeting on July 23, 2025, focusing on the preservation of local heritage trees and community concerns. The commission approved the removal of two valley oak trees while denying a request to remove a healthy Deodar cedar tree, reflecting a commitment to maintaining the town's green spaces.

The discussion centered around a property located at 285 Camino Al Lago, where the applicant sought to remove three trees to accommodate a proposed driveway. The town arborist supported the removal of the two valley oaks due to health concerns but recommended retaining the Deodar cedar, which was deemed to be in good health. The arborist suggested that pruning could mitigate any potential hazards posed by the cedar tree, and that the driveway's design could be adjusted to preserve it.

Community members expressed their concerns during the public comment section, emphasizing the importance of the trees for neighborhood aesthetics and environmental health. One resident highlighted the need for better communication with the applicant, who was absent from the meeting, and urged the commission to consider alternatives to tree removal.

In a notable outcome, the commission directed staff to verify the dimensions of another tree near a proposed fountain, which was close to the threshold for heritage status. This decision underscores the commission's proactive approach to tree preservation and community engagement.

The meeting concluded with a clear message: while development is necessary, it should not come at the expense of the town's natural heritage. The commission's decisions reflect a balance between progress and environmental stewardship, aiming to protect Atherton's unique character for future generations.