San Mateo Council Faces Public Outcry Over Bike Lanes and Mills Act Contracts

During the San Mateo City Council meeting on July 28, 2025, residents voiced strong concerns regarding the city's financial decisions and infrastructure projects, highlighting the need for greater accountability and community engagement.

One of the most pressing issues raised was the Mills Act, which allows for property tax reductions for homeowners who maintain historic properties. A resident criticized the council for approving contracts that cost the city $52,000 annually, questioning the benefits to the community and urging a thorough investigation into the program's implementation. The speaker emphasized that the financial burden on taxpayers should not subsidize wealthy homeowners without clear returns for the city, such as tourism or economic benefits. They called for immediate action to prevent the automatic renewal of these contracts, which could further impact the city's revenue.

Another significant topic was the ongoing review of historic ordinances, particularly concerning the Baywood area. A speaker expressed concern that city staff might be making critical decisions without adequate public input. They urged the council to ensure that a range of policy options is presented to the community before any decisions are finalized, emphasizing the importance of transparency and public participation in shaping local regulations.

Additionally, the effectiveness of bike lanes in San Mateo was scrutinized. A resident reported that bike lanes, including those on Humboldt Street, are underutilized, averaging less than three trips per day. They argued that the lanes are unsafe, particularly for children, and called for their removal to protect residents and restore parking spaces that had been eliminated. This sentiment was echoed by community members who expressed frustration over the perceived inequity in prioritizing bike lanes over parking in certain neighborhoods.

As the council moves forward, these discussions highlight the need for a balanced approach to urban planning and fiscal responsibility, ensuring that community voices are heard and considered in decision-making processes. The outcomes of these deliberations will play a crucial role in shaping the future of San Mateo, as residents seek solutions that prioritize safety, transparency, and equitable resource allocation.