The Fairhope City Council convened on July 28, 2025, to discuss various agenda items, prominently featuring the proposed 10-year lease exemption for Theater 98. The meeting included public comments from community members, highlighting differing perspectives on the theater's performance and community engagement.

The first speaker, a former county government purchasing director and active participant in Theater 98 productions, raised concerns regarding the theater's compliance with lease requirements. He pointed out that while the lease mandates at least four performances per year aimed at the local community, particularly youth and seniors, there have been no productions specifically targeting young audiences since 2005. He emphasized that this lack of engagement represents a significant failure in fulfilling the lease's terms. Additionally, he noted that the theater's facility does not meet current building codes, raising questions about safety and long-term viability. He urged the council to consider these factors when evaluating the lease agreement, advocating for a more comprehensive benefit to the community.

Following this, Jennifer Walker, a current board member of Theater 98, defended the theater's operations. She acknowledged the challenges of maintaining a historic building but asserted that the theater fulfills its lease obligations by providing free performances targeted at seniors and students. Walker emphasized the board's commitment to continuous improvements and maintenance of the facility, despite its age. She clarified that while the theater primarily features adult productions, it allows youth to attend performances at no cost, thus fulfilling the spirit of community engagement.

The council members engaged with both speakers, seeking clarity on the theater's governance and community outreach efforts. The discussions highlighted the balance between maintaining a historic venue and ensuring it serves the evolving needs of the Fairhope community.

As the meeting concluded, the council was tasked with considering the implications of the lease terms and the theater's role in the community, with a focus on maximizing the benefits for Fairhope residents. Further discussions and decisions regarding the lease are anticipated in future council meetings.