Fire Chief Suspects Captain Flagg Tampered With Rig Floor Camera

The Elkhart Fire Merit Commission convened on July 28, 2025, to discuss a disciplinary action involving Captain Dustin Flagg, who received a 24-hour suspension for allegedly tampering with a camera at the fire station. The meeting highlighted the investigation process that led to this decision, which included input from human resources and a reenactment of the incident.

Fire Chief emphasized that while there was significant pressure to impose a harsher penalty, including termination or demotion, he opted for a 24-hour suspension, believing it to be a fair consequence for a probationary captain. He noted that Flagg displayed poor leadership by disconnecting the camera, which was installed to monitor activities on the rig floor. The chief acknowledged the emotional context surrounding the new camera system, which had been a source of tension within the department.

During the meeting, it was revealed that the camera was unplugged shortly before it went offline, and while no one witnessed the act, the evidence suggested a strong correlation between Flagg's actions and the camera's disconnection. The chief defended his decision, stating that he had taken into account Flagg's lack of prior disciplinary issues and the need for accountability within the department.

The commission also discussed procedural aspects of the disciplinary process, confirming that Flagg had filed an objection to the discipline within the required 48-hour timeframe. The meeting concluded with a focus on maintaining integrity within the fire department while balancing the need for fair treatment of its members.