The morning docket of the 187th District Court in Texas on July 29, 2025, focused on the case of Elizabeth Settle, who faced serious charges related to drug offenses. The court convened to discuss the results of a recent drug test and the implications for Settle's future, particularly concerning her eligibility for probation and participation in a drug court program.
During the proceedings, it was revealed that Settle tested positive for substances related to her medication-assisted treatment, with no other drugs detected. Judge Stephanie Boyd acknowledged the complexity of Settle's situation, noting her status as a mother and the apparent positive changes in her life. The judge expressed concern about Settle's past behavior, including previous failures to comply with court orders and the impact of her actions on her family and community.
The state prosecutor argued for a prison sentence, citing Settle's history and the need for accountability, while also recognizing the potential for rehabilitation. Settle's defense attorney highlighted her compliance with court requirements since her last arrest, including participation in programs and maintaining contact with her child. The attorney urged the court to consider therapeutic justice rather than incarceration, suggesting that continued support could lead to lasting change.
Ultimately, Judge Boyd offered Settle a choice between immediate sentencing to prison or a deferred adjudication that would allow her to enter a drug court program. The judge emphasized the importance of structured supervision and compliance with court orders, including community service and parenting classes. Settle was granted deferred adjudication for one charge and a suspended sentence for another, with conditions including regular reporting and random drug tests.
The court scheduled a restitution hearing for September 11, 2025, to address any financial obligations Settle may have towards her victims. The outcome of this case underscores the court's balancing act between enforcing the law and providing opportunities for rehabilitation, particularly for individuals with a history of substance abuse.