The Design Review Commission of San Gabriel convened on July 28, 2025, to discuss several key projects, including a significant residential development proposal. The meeting primarily focused on a luxury home project that has raised concerns among commissioners regarding its design and environmental impact.

During the meeting, commissioners expressed the need for additional documentation before making a decision on the proposed luxury home. A critical point of discussion was the requirement for an arborist report to assess the health and impact of existing trees on the property. Commissioners emphasized that understanding the tree situation is vital for both the property owner and the surrounding community. They also requested a material board to clarify the quality and colors of materials intended for use in the construction.

The discussion highlighted the historical context of design reviews in San Gabriel, particularly regarding the trend of large homes, often referred to as "McMansions." One commissioner noted that while the proposed home is large, it does not violate any zoning regulations, as the lot size accommodates the structure. However, there was a consensus that the design must reflect the luxury status of the home, aligning with the standards of neighboring properties.

The commission ultimately decided to continue the review of the project, allowing the applicant time to address the concerns raised. They encouraged the applicant to bring the arborist to the next meeting to answer any questions regarding the report. Additionally, the commission requested that the applicant work closely with landscape architects and contractors to ensure that all design elements, including fencing, are well-coordinated.

The motion to continue the project was unanimously approved, with the commission looking forward to a more comprehensive proposal in the future. The meeting concluded with a brief break before moving on to the next agenda item, which involved a separate residential development project.