Painters Hill Residents Criticize Seawall Plan and Advocate for Beach Nourishment Solutions

The Joint Cities and Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) Workshop held on August 5, 2025, in Flagler County, Florida, focused on critical discussions regarding coastal protection strategies, particularly the effectiveness of seawalls versus beach nourishment.

The meeting began with a resident from the Paintershall section expressing strong opposition to a proposal that emphasized sand replenishment without adequate consideration for bulkheads and seawalls. The speaker highlighted concerns about the potential impact of future storms, arguing that relying solely on sand would be insufficient for long-term coastal protection. He referenced his military experience, emphasizing the importance of durable structures like steel ships, which are designed to withstand severe weather conditions.

The resident pointed out that some properties in Paintershall had been forced to install seawalls, incurring significant costs, and criticized the county for not providing adequate support to homeowners seeking to protect their properties. He urged the commissioners to reconsider their approach, suggesting that a more comprehensive plan was necessary to address the community's needs effectively.

In response, another participant acknowledged the concerns raised about seawalls, noting that while they provide some protection, they are not a standalone solution. He explained that seawalls require ongoing beach nourishment to remain effective, as erosion can undermine their stability. This participant emphasized that beach nourishment projects not only extend the beach but also help protect the dune system by dissipating wave energy further from the shore.

Commissioner Hansen reiterated the points made about the high costs associated with seawalls, stating that they are significantly more expensive than beach nourishment efforts. He reinforced the idea that a combination of both strategies is essential for effective coastal management, as neglecting beach replenishment could lead to the failure of seawalls over time.

The workshop concluded with a consensus on the need for a balanced approach to coastal protection, recognizing the importance of both seawalls and beach nourishment in safeguarding the community against future storm impacts. The discussions highlighted the complexities of coastal management and the necessity for ongoing education and collaboration among stakeholders to develop effective solutions.