Winchester Board Debates $100M Contract with Gilbert School amid Legal Concerns

A heated discussion over legal representation and contract negotiations took center stage at the Winchester Board of Education meeting on May 13, 2025. Board members expressed concerns about the ongoing legal fees and the effectiveness of their current attorney, Shipman and Goodwin, particularly regarding a significant contract with the W.L. Gilbert School Corporation.

One board member questioned whether attorney Stephen Harding had provided any pro bono work or if he was billing the board, highlighting a lack of communication and transparency. The discussion quickly escalated as members debated the qualifications of municipal attorneys versus specialized educational attorneys, with some arguing that the complexities of special education law require expertise that municipal attorneys may lack.

Concerns were raised about the rising legal costs, which have already reached $32,000, and the potential for further expenses if the board continues to seek multiple legal opinions. One member emphasized the importance of due diligence in negotiating a contract that could amount to $90 million over ten years, urging the board to ensure they receive the best legal counsel.

The conversation also touched on the need for community input regarding the contract, with suggestions for surveys or referendums to gauge public opinion. As tensions rose, members debated the necessity of reconstituting the committee overseeing the contract negotiations to ensure bipartisan representation and effective decision-making.

Ultimately, the board voted against cutting off debate, allowing discussions to continue as they seek a resolution that serves the best interests of the community and the students. The meeting underscored the complexities and challenges facing the board as they navigate legal and financial responsibilities in their educational commitments.