Trustees Medina Andano and Butegra face Sarasota hearing on vacation rental violations

A recent Code Compliance Hearing in Sarasota highlighted the city's ongoing efforts to regulate vacation rentals, with a focus on compliance and penalties for violations. The hearing, held on August 7, 2025, addressed a case involving a property owner who received a notice of violation for operating an Airbnb without the necessary registration.

The property owner, who resides in New York, explained that upon receiving the notice dated April 11, they promptly removed the property from Airbnb listings. They emphasized their intent to comply with city regulations, stating, "We have not rented the property since receiving the notice." However, the owner acknowledged a delay in opening the letter, which resulted in a missed compliance deadline.

City officials noted that while the owner acted quickly once aware of the violation, the responsibility for timely communication rests with the property owner. The magistrate ultimately decided on a $490 fine, which included a $100 penalty and $390 for inspection costs. The magistrate remarked, "Your prompt and speedy action... resulted in far less of a penalty than it would have been, had you not taken the immediate action that you did."

The hearing also touched on the broader implications of vacation rental regulations in Sarasota, as officials reiterated the importance of compliance to maintain community standards. The property owner was informed about the payment process and the distinction between the inspection fee and future registration requirements.

As Sarasota continues to navigate the complexities of vacation rental regulations, this case serves as a reminder of the city's commitment to enforcing compliance while also recognizing the efforts of property owners to adhere to the rules. The outcome underscores the importance of timely communication and the potential consequences of delays in addressing violations.