The Newport Historic District Commission convened on August 12, 2025, to discuss a significant application concerning the renovation of a historic property. The meeting focused on the proposed changes to the main house and its carriage house, with particular attention to the materials and architectural features that define the property’s historic character.

The discussion began with a review of the application, where concerns were raised about the materials used in the existing structure, particularly on the east side. Commission members expressed uncertainty regarding the original materials and whether they should be retained. It was noted that the property owner had previously made changes without permission, and should the commission deny the current application, the owner would be required to restore the property to its prior condition.

Architect Mark Rapp presented the proposed changes, starting with the east elevation, which is set to become the primary facade of the house. The proposal includes the addition of a small portico and new entry door, along with windows that would mimic the existing design. Rapp emphasized that the current sliding doors were not original and did not contribute to the historic character of the property.

The west elevation was discussed next, where it was noted that some original features would be preserved, including a four-panel door and a double-hung window. However, some non-original elements would be replaced to restore the facade's integrity.

The commission then reviewed the south elevation, where Rapp outlined plans to maintain the primary chimney while removing a later-added buttress that served no structural purpose. The discussion highlighted the importance of retaining character-defining features, such as the fieldstone exterior.

Throughout the meeting, commission members raised questions about the need for a detailed window inventory to assess the significance of existing windows. Concerns were voiced regarding the potential loss of historic materials and the need for clarity on the proposed changes to ensure they align with preservation standards.

As the meeting progressed, the commission deliberated on the implications of the proposed alterations, emphasizing the need for careful consideration of the building's historical context. The discussion concluded with a consensus to gather more information before making a final decision on the application, ensuring that any changes would respect the property's historic character and integrity.

The commission plans to reconvene to further evaluate the application, with a focus on preserving the historical significance of the property while accommodating necessary renovations.