Historic Landmarks Commission Approves Ghirardelli Parklet Redesign in El Pueblo Viejo

The Historic Landmarks Commission (HLC) of Santa Barbara convened on August 13, 2025, to discuss significant alterations to a historic site at 509 State Street, as well as a new parklet proposal for the Press Room on East Ortega Street. The meeting highlighted the balance between preserving historical integrity and accommodating modern business needs.

The primary focus was on the proposed project at 509 State Street, which is recognized as a contributing historic resource within the El Pueblo Viejo Landmark District. The project involves replacing existing patio pendant lights and string lights with new fixtures, as well as adding a mosaic tile wall. The commission confirmed that the proposed mosaics would be classified as murals under the municipal code, limiting the HLC's oversight to their size and location. This classification sparked discussions about the artistic and commercial implications of the project, with some commissioners expressing concerns that the large size of the proposed mosaics could overshadow the historic character of the building.

Commissioners debated the aesthetics of the proposed tiles, with suggestions to consider larger, more traditional Spanish tile sizes to better align with the architectural style of Santa Barbara. The discussion also touched on the visibility of the mosaics from State Street, with some members advocating for a design that would enhance the viewer's experience without compromising the building's historical significance.

In addition to the State Street project, the commission reviewed a proposal for a parklet in front of the Press Room. The parklet aims to enhance the outdoor dining experience while maintaining compliance with city regulations. Public comments overwhelmingly supported the parklet, emphasizing its role in revitalizing the area post-COVID-19. The design includes natural materials and a simplified aesthetic, which aligns with the community's desire for a more inviting public space.

The HLC ultimately decided to continue the discussion on the State Street project, requesting the applicant to revise the design based on the commission's feedback regarding size, material, and overall aesthetic. The parklet proposal received positive feedback, with the commission expressing a willingness to support its implementation.

As the meeting concluded, the HLC underscored the importance of balancing historical preservation with contemporary business needs, reflecting the ongoing challenge of maintaining Santa Barbara's unique architectural heritage while fostering a vibrant community atmosphere. The next steps for both projects will involve further revisions and presentations to ensure that they meet the city's standards for historic preservation and community engagement.