Commissioners Review Proposed Home Addition and Carriage House Design in Columbus

The Victorian Village Commission held a special meeting on August 13, 2025, to discuss proposed renovations to a residential property, focusing on an addition and a carriage house. The meeting highlighted concerns regarding the design, scale, and materials of the proposed changes.

The primary discussion centered on a proposed addition to the existing home, which the owners aim to enhance for family gatherings and outdoor entertainment. The addition's height was a significant concern, with the commission suggesting adjustments to ensure it remains compatible with the existing structure. The owners expressed willingness to modify the design, including reducing ceiling heights to comply with guidelines.

Commission members emphasized the importance of maintaining architectural harmony within the neighborhood. They raised issues about the addition's roofline and overall massing, suggesting that it should be subordinate to the main house. The commission recommended exploring alternative designs that would preserve the character of the original structure while accommodating the owners' needs.

In addition to the main house, the proposed carriage house also drew scrutiny. Commissioners noted that its size appeared disproportionate to typical accessory structures in the area. They urged the owners to consider a smaller footprint that aligns with the guidelines for accessory buildings.

The meeting concluded with a consensus that further revisions are necessary before the proposals can be approved. The commission encouraged the owners to refine their designs, focusing on compatibility with the existing architecture and the overall aesthetic of Victorian Village. The next steps will involve continued dialogue between the homeowners and the commission to ensure the project aligns with community standards and expectations.