Galveston Commission Approves Demolition of 1917 Garage Apartment Amid Structural Concerns

The Galveston Landmark Commission made a significant decision during its recent meeting on August 18, 2025, approving the demolition of a deteriorating garage apartment at 1923 Avenue M. The structure, believed to date back to 1917, was deemed unsafe and beyond repair by both the applicant and expert contractors who assessed its condition.

The commission's approval came after a public hearing where Greg Lewis, representing the property owners, detailed the extensive damage to the building. He noted that the structure had suffered severe deterioration, with compromised supports and unsafe electrical work. Lewis emphasized that the building's condition made it impractical to salvage, stating, "If we start doing anything with that foundation... it's not going to survive."

The commission's staff report supported the demolition, highlighting that while alley houses are important features of Galveston's neighborhoods, this particular structure did not hold significant historical value. The report indicated that the building's age and condition warranted the decision, and it encouraged the reuse of any salvaged materials in future construction.

Following the motion to approve the demolition, the commission voted unanimously in favor, allowing the property owners to move forward with plans for a new garage apartment that would better serve their needs. The commission anticipates that the new construction will enhance the property's value while maintaining the historic character of the area.

This decision marks a pivotal moment for the Landmark Commission as it balances the preservation of Galveston's historical architecture with the practical needs of its residents. The next steps will involve the submission of a new design proposal for the future garage apartment, ensuring that it aligns with the city's design standards.