The City of Miami's Civil Service Board convened on August 19, 2025, to address significant matters concerning employee rights and whistleblower protections. The meeting focused primarily on the case of an employee, Mr. Matias, who was terminated under allegations that raised concerns about potential whistleblower retaliation.

The session began with board member Soleiman expressing apprehension regarding the board's ability to make a fair determination based solely on written documents. Soleiman emphasized the importance of hearing from witnesses directly, particularly those involved in the decision to suspend or terminate Mr. Matias. The board discussed the limitations of relying on paper evidence alone, noting that the previous hearings had included extensive witness testimonies that provided crucial context.

In response, board members acknowledged the need for thorough review of the documentation and suggested that if any member felt additional information was necessary, they could request specific witnesses to be brought in for questioning. This approach aims to ensure that all relevant perspectives are considered before reaching a conclusion.

The board also discussed the availability of recordings from previous hearings, which could serve as a valuable resource for members as they review the case. It was proposed that these recordings, along with the written transcripts, would help clarify any uncertainties and enhance understanding of the evidence presented.

Additionally, the board agreed to stipulate that all evidence from prior hearings would be included in the current record, ensuring that members have access to all relevant materials as they deliberate on the case.

As the meeting concluded, the board members expressed their commitment to a fair and comprehensive review process, with plans to gather all necessary documents and recordings before the next scheduled hearing. This proactive approach underscores the board's dedication to upholding civil service standards and protecting employee rights within the City of Miami.