Hawaiian Council Votes to Support Private Road Improvements in Puna Districts

The Hawaii County Council convened on August 20, 2025, to discuss critical issues affecting local communities, particularly focusing on road maintenance in private subdivisions. A significant topic of debate was Bill 38, which aims to provide financial relief for residents of Puna facing challenges due to deteriorating private roads.

Council member Kenely E. Kleinfelder, who introduced the bill, emphasized the urgent need for support in Puna, where many residents have been left to manage their own road maintenance after the county's decisions led to the creation of non-conforming subdivisions. Fellow council member Kerkowitz echoed this sentiment, highlighting the difficult conditions first responders encounter while serving these communities. He expressed gratitude for the bill, noting that while it may not resolve all issues, it represents a step toward addressing the ongoing struggles faced by residents.

However, not all council members were fully supportive. Council member Kaguaro raised concerns about the bill potentially benefiting those who can afford to pay for road maintenance, suggesting that the financial relief might not adequately support the most vulnerable residents. He called for a reevaluation of the funding amount to ensure it aligns with the needs of those truly struggling.

Council member Eustace also voiced reservations, questioning whether the bill would encourage homeowners to take responsibility for their roads. He pointed out that many homeowners associations (HOAs) lack mandatory fees, which could lead to a lack of ownership and commitment to road upkeep. Eustace urged for a more robust approach to ensure that residents actively participate in maintaining their infrastructure.

Despite these concerns, the council ultimately voted in favor of Bill 38, with eight members supporting it and one opposing. The bill's passage marks a significant move towards addressing the infrastructure challenges in Puna, although its long-term effectiveness remains to be seen.

In addition to Bill 38, the council also discussed Bill 60, which was introduced later in the meeting. Testimony was provided by Claudia Rohrer, a long-time resident of the Leili'i neighborhood, indicating ongoing community engagement in local governance.

As the council continues to navigate these complex issues, the focus remains on finding solutions that not only provide immediate relief but also foster long-term responsibility and improvement within the community. The discussions reflect a broader commitment to enhancing the quality of life for residents across Hawaii County.