New Bedford City Council debates police chief confirmation amid legal opinions

The New Bedford City Council convened on August 21, 2025, to address a significant issue regarding the confirmation of the newly appointed police chief, a matter that has sparked considerable debate among council members. The discussion centered on whether the police chief should be confirmed by the council, as stipulated in the city charter, which mandates that all department heads be appointed by the mayor with council approval.

Councilor Morath emphasized the importance of public awareness regarding the council's role in this process, urging residents to voice their concerns through letters to state representatives and the governor. This call to action reflects a growing sentiment among council members that the confirmation process is not merely procedural but a fundamental aspect of their governance responsibilities.

Attorney Gary Garatowski provided legal insights, asserting that the police chief is indeed a department head and thus requires council confirmation. He pointed out that previous chiefs had been confirmed by the council, establishing a precedent that should be upheld. The attorney's interpretation of the city charter suggests that any attempt to exempt the police chief from this requirement would violate the charter's provisions.

The council's deliberations revealed a divide in opinions on how to proceed. Some members advocated for a direct approach, suggesting a motion to compel the mayor to submit the chief's appointment for confirmation. Others expressed concerns about the potential implications of pursuing legal action, emphasizing the need for unity and collaboration with the mayor's office.

Ultimately, the council voted to instruct Attorney Garatowski to file a complaint in court seeking a declaratory judgment on the matter. This decision underscores the council's commitment to asserting its authority and clarifying its role in the appointment process, which could have lasting implications for future governance in New Bedford.

As the council navigates this complex issue, the outcome will not only determine the status of the new police chief but also set a precedent for the balance of power between the mayor's office and the city council, shaping the future of municipal governance in New Bedford.