Design Changes Approved for New Mother House in Downtown St Augustine

The St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) made significant strides in its recent meeting on August 21, 2025, focusing on the proposed design changes for a new mother house for the Sisters of St. Joseph. The board reviewed modifications aimed at addressing previous concerns regarding the building's massing and scale, particularly along Cadiz and Aviles Streets.

The applicant, represented by Christina Evans from Matthews DCCM, presented revised plans that included a reduction in the overall building height by eight inches, bringing it to a maximum of 47 feet 1 inch. This adjustment was made to enhance ADA accessibility while ensuring the new structure remains compatible with the existing mother house, which stands at approximately 46.5 feet. Notably, the design now features balconies and architectural projections that break up previously flat surfaces, contributing to a more visually appealing facade.

The board also discussed the importance of emergency vehicle access, with recommendations for a wider gated entry along Saint George Street to accommodate such needs. The proposed design changes were well-received, with board members acknowledging the responsiveness of the design team to previous feedback. The incorporation of balconies and the reconfiguration of internal spaces were highlighted as effective strategies to soften the building's appearance and integrate it better into the surrounding historic context.

In addition to the main project, the board addressed other minor topics, including the need for further details on materials and design elements in future submissions. The meeting concluded with a positive outlook on the proposed changes, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the architectural integrity of St. Augustine while accommodating modern needs.

As the project moves forward, the HARB will continue to evaluate the design to ensure it aligns with the city's historic preservation goals, reflecting a commitment to both community needs and architectural heritage.