St. Augustine Board Reviews Renovation Plans for Historic St. George Street Storefronts

The St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) convened on August 21, 2025, to discuss proposed renovations for a historic commercial building located at the corner of St. George and Treasury Streets. The building, constructed in the 1930s and part of the St. Augustine National Register Historic District, is undergoing a reconfiguration of its storefronts to enhance its appearance while adhering to preservation guidelines.

The applicant, Lynn Week, along with building owners Anne and Dave Border, presented plans to reconfigure two existing storefronts, previously combined into one unit, to bring them flush with the wall and add new awnings. The proposed design aims to reflect traditional commercial architecture while maintaining the building's historical integrity. The storefronts currently exhibit mid-century design elements, and the proposed changes are intended to create a more cohesive look along St. George Street.

HARB members expressed support for the proposed alterations, particularly the addition of wood doors and awnings, which they believe will enhance the building's aesthetic. However, there were concerns regarding the color palette selected for the renovations. Some board members questioned whether the proposed colors align with the building's architectural style, which is more reflective of Mediterranean influences rather than colonial revival styles.

The board discussed the significance of retaining historical features and the potential for flexibility in design, given the building's long history and the alterations it has undergone over the years. The discussion highlighted the challenges of coordinating renovations among multiple tenants, each with their preferences for storefront aesthetics.

In conclusion, the board is considering approving the application as submitted or with modifications, allowing the applicant time to refine the color choices and design elements. The outcome of this meeting will play a crucial role in shaping the future appearance of this historic building, ensuring it remains a vital part of St. Augustine's architectural heritage.