Design Board Continues Review of Downtown St Augustine Building Plans

In a recent meeting of the St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB), discussions centered on the design and architectural details of a significant new development. Board members expressed a strong desire for the project to reflect the historic character of the area while ensuring modern functionality.

Key points of contention included the scale and massing of the proposed building. Board members emphasized the importance of creating a cohesive design that respects the historic context of St. Augustine. One member noted, “We need to see more of that in the final product,” referring to the need for architectural details that echo the historic mother house, while also allowing for contemporary elements.

The conversation also highlighted the balance between natural light and architectural aesthetics. Board members debated the size of windows on the upper floors, with a preference for maintaining openness while considering the visual impact from the street. “It’s a balance between what the sisters are gonna have on this particular view,” one member remarked, underscoring the need for thoughtful design that enhances the pedestrian experience.

Another significant topic was the potential for a courtyard to serve as a delivery area, raising questions about the necessity of automobile access from Saint George Street. One board member suggested that eliminating the driveway could enhance the site’s aesthetics and provide more space for gardens, stating, “It seems like it’s driving the design of this as a general concept.”

The board ultimately decided to continue the discussion to the next meeting, scheduled for September 18, allowing the developers time to refine their plans and address the board's concerns. The consensus was clear: while there is support for the project, careful attention to detail and context is essential to ensure that the new development complements the historic fabric of St. Augustine.