City Officials Outline Tree Maintenance Plans Amid Concerns of Deferred Maintenance

The Forest and Beach Commission of Carmel-by-the-Sea convened on August 21, 2025, to address critical issues surrounding tree maintenance and forest health within the city. The meeting highlighted the ongoing challenges of deferred maintenance in the city's mature forest, as well as the importance of balancing public messaging regarding tree removal.

One of the primary discussions centered on the city's three-year catch-up plan for tree maintenance, which is currently in its second year. Officials acknowledged that while the city promotes the preservation of healthy trees, there are instances where trees on both public and private properties require removal due to health concerns or safety hazards. The commission emphasized the need for clear communication to residents about the necessity of tree inspections and potential removals that may arise from these assessments.

The conversation also touched on the role of certified foresters in evaluating tree health. City staff are not trained foresters, and therefore rely on experts to determine the condition of trees, especially those that may appear healthy one week and show signs of distress the next. The commission noted that trees affected by diseases or pests pose risks not only to the forest ecosystem but also to personal property and public safety.

As the city continues its inspection process, officials are committed to identifying dead or dying trees and ensuring that they are addressed promptly. The commission reiterated the importance of adhering to city regulations regarding tree trimming and removal, which can vary from one municipality to another.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the city's proactive approach to forest management while recognizing the complexities involved in maintaining a healthy urban forest. The commission plans to continue its efforts in tree maintenance and public education to ensure the safety and well-being of the community.