Warren Committee Debates Conditional Use Permit for Handyman Business at 90 First Street

A proposed handyman business in St. Croix County is at the center of a heated discussion among local officials, as the Community Development Committee weighs the implications of a conditional use permit (CUP) request. The application, which seeks to operate a home-based handyman service with some on-site repairs, has raised concerns about zoning compliance and neighborhood impact.

The applicant, Jared Norris, currently runs a small handyman business from his residence on 90 First Street. He claims that only about 10% of his work is conducted on-site, primarily in his garage, with the majority of services provided off-site. Norris emphasized that he adheres to proper disposal methods for any fluids and maintains a respectful relationship with his neighbors, stating, "I try to be respectful to my neighbors... no one has ever had an issue with noise or hours of operation."

However, committee members expressed reservations about the business's fit within the R2 zoning district, noting that the proposed use does not fully align with either home occupation or contractor storage yard definitions. Concerns were raised regarding the visibility of vehicles and equipment on the property, with suggestions for additional screening to mitigate potential neighborhood disturbances.

The committee also highlighted the absence of feedback from the town of Warren, which could influence the decision-making process. Some members suggested tabling the application until they receive input from local officials, emphasizing the importance of community consensus in such matters.

As the committee deliberates, the future of Norris's handyman business hangs in the balance, with potential outcomes ranging from approval to further review. The next steps will likely involve gathering more information and community feedback before a final decision is made.