Architect Matt Mutschler gains variances for new garage at Blue Park property

In the heart of Grove City, under the watchful gaze of city hall, a pivotal discussion unfolded regarding the construction of a new accessory building that could reshape the neighborhood's landscape. On August 25, 2025, the Grove City Board of Zoning Appeals convened to deliberate on a variance request from local architect Matt Mutschler, representing homeowners David and Julia Logsdon.

The Logsdons, who are currently building their home on Cassidy Drive, sought approval for a detached garage that would measure 676 square feet. This request came with several variances, including exceeding the maximum allowable garage area and height. The proposed garage would bring the total garage area on the property to 1,314 square feet, surpassing the 900-square-foot limit by 414 square feet. Additionally, the garage's wall height would reach 13 feet 3.25 inches, exceeding the 8-foot maximum by over 5 feet, and the overall height would be 20 feet, surpassing the 13-foot limit by 7 feet.

Mutschler explained that the design aims to harmonize with the existing attached garage, aligning eave lines and matching roof pitch to maintain aesthetic consistency. The garage is intended not just for vehicle storage but also as an engineering office and workshop for Mr. Logsdon, who is an engineer by profession.

The board's discussion included inquiries about the lot size, which is approximately one acre, providing ample space for both the home and the two garages. The corner lot's design was noted for enhancing neighborhood privacy and streetscape, particularly with the garage positioned near an alley.

Community engagement was also a focal point of the meeting. Notifications were sent to nearby residents, and the only response came from a neighboring property owner who expressed support for the variance, indicating a positive reception from the community.

After thorough deliberation, the board unanimously approved the appeal, granting the requested variances. However, they cautioned that the City Council could still reverse their decision within a 21-day waiting period, a rare occurrence in their experience.

As the meeting concluded, the Logsdons were one step closer to realizing their vision for a functional and aesthetically pleasing addition to their property, a project that promises to blend seamlessly into the fabric of the Grove City community.