Butte County Library proposes fine amnesty month and two-year fine-free pilot program

Butte County Library is set to launch a significant initiative aimed at improving community access to library services by establishing a fine-free library system. During the Board of Supervisors meeting on August 26, 2025, Library Director Misty Wright proposed a resolution for a one-time library fine amnesty month in September, alongside a two-year pilot program to eliminate daily fines on overdue materials.

Currently, the library charges $0.25 per day for overdue items, which has not proven effective in recovering lost materials. Wright highlighted that only 10% of lost items could be replaced through the revenue generated from fines. The proposed amnesty month will encourage patrons to return overdue materials without the burden of fines, while also allowing them to clear their accounts by contacting the library.

The pilot program aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of a fine-free system. Under this model, patrons will no longer incur daily charges for overdue items. Instead, if items are not returned within 30 days, replacement costs will be charged to the account, which will be waived upon the return of the items. This approach is designed to foster a more welcoming environment, particularly for low-income families who are disproportionately affected by fines.

Wright cited successful examples from over 600 libraries nationwide that have adopted similar fine-free policies, noting significant increases in the return of materials and improved patron engagement. For instance, the Chicago Public Library reported a 240% increase in returned items after eliminating fines.

The Board of Supervisors is expected to approve the resolution for the amnesty month and the pilot program, which will begin this fall. This initiative not only aims to recover lost materials but also to enhance community interaction with library services and support educational programs mandated by the California Student Success Act.