Commissioner Supports ADU Project Amid Design Concerns Over Architectural Flare

During a recent meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission in Boise, discussions centered around a proposed project that has sparked both support and concern among commissioners. The project, which involves the design of an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), was met with mixed reviews regarding its aesthetic elements.

One commissioner expressed a preference for a more understated design, suggesting that the current flair might be excessive. However, they acknowledged the overall quality of the project, noting that it does not overwhelm the lot size. This sentiment was echoed by another commissioner who voiced their support for the project, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the character of the neighborhood while allowing for modern developments.

Concerns were raised about specific design features, including the height of the structure. Some commissioners debated whether minor adjustments, such as reducing the height by 6 to 18 inches, were necessary. Despite these concerns, there was a consensus that certain design elements, like the 3 over 1 windows, contribute positively to the project’s appeal.

The discussion highlighted the balance between preserving historical aesthetics and accommodating new construction. The commissioners recognized the need to distinguish new designs from existing historical residences, with one member pointing out that lighter colors used in the front of the house could help achieve this goal.

As the commission moves forward, the outcome of this project will play a significant role in shaping Boise's architectural landscape, reflecting the community's values of preservation and innovation. The next steps will involve further deliberation on the design elements to ensure they align with the city’s historic preservation goals while meeting the needs of modern residents.