Franklin Street Residents Advocate for New Porch Construction Amid Guideline Concerns

The Dublin Architectural Review Board (ARB) convened on August 27, 2025, to discuss a proposed front porch addition at 85 Franklin Street, a matter that has sparked considerable community interest. The meeting highlighted the balance between preserving the neighborhood's historic character and accommodating residents' desires for functional outdoor spaces.

The primary focus of the discussion was the proposed porch's dimensions and its alignment with the city's architectural guidelines. The applicant, Erin and Elena Frank, expressed their need for a porch to provide shade and enhance community engagement. They emphasized the importance of a front porch for social interaction, stating that it would allow them to connect with neighbors while also addressing the heat issues caused by the sun exposure on their home.

ARB member Miss Holt clarified that the guidelines for the neighborhood, updated in 2023-2024, aim to maintain the architectural integrity of Franklin Street, which is recognized as a background neighborhood. Concerns were raised about the porch's depth and its potential encroachment on the established building setback, which is crucial for maintaining a consistent streetscape. The board noted that while the proposed porch would extend seven feet from the house, it would still be set back approximately 53 feet from the street, aligning with the setbacks of other homes in the area.

Public comments during the meeting reflected strong support for the porch addition. Neighbors highlighted the positive impact of front porches on community interaction and the aesthetic value they bring to the neighborhood. Michael Strang, a resident directly adjacent to the proposed site, argued that the porch would enhance the neighborhood's appeal and promote a sense of community.

The board members engaged in a thoughtful discussion about the design elements, including the number of columns supporting the porch and the roofing material. While some members expressed a preference for a standing seam roof due to its low maintenance, others were open to considering alternatives that would blend seamlessly with the existing home.

As the meeting progressed, it became clear that the board was leaning towards a compromise that would allow the porch while addressing the concerns about its size and design. The discussion underscored the importance of balancing individual homeowner needs with the broader goals of preserving the neighborhood's character.

In conclusion, the ARB's deliberations on the porch addition at 85 Franklin Street reflect a community grappling with the challenges of modernization while honoring its historical roots. The board's eventual decision will not only impact the Frank family but also set a precedent for future developments in Dublin's historic districts, highlighting the ongoing dialogue between preservation and progress.