Commissioners Begin Hearing on Evidence Presentation in Hatcher Case

The Tennessee POST Commission held a formal hearing on August 29, 2025, focusing on the presentation of evidence related to ongoing allegations. The meeting began with opening statements from attorneys representing both the department and the respondents. Following these statements, the commission moved into the evidence presentation phase, where the department was set to present its case first.

During the hearing, the process for presenting evidence was outlined. Witnesses would provide testimony in response to questions from the attorneys, with opportunities for cross-examination. The commission emphasized the distinction between direct and circumstantial evidence, explaining that both types would be considered in their deliberations. Direct evidence is defined as firsthand proof, while circumstantial evidence provides indirect clues that can lead to conclusions about the facts of the case.

The commissioners were reminded that they are the sole judges of the credibility of witnesses and that they should weigh the evidence based on reason and common sense, rather than simply counting the number of witnesses on each side. The burden of proof lies with the department, which must establish its case by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning that the allegations must be shown to be more likely true than not.

As the hearing progressed, Deputy Chief Brent Hatcher from the Wilbur News Department was called to testify, marking the beginning of the testimony phase. The commission's proceedings are designed to ensure a fair evaluation of the evidence presented, with further legal instructions to be provided after all evidence has been heard. The outcome of this hearing could have significant implications for the parties involved, depending on the findings of the commission.