Historic Preservation Board Debates Vertical Siding for O'Connor Home Renovation

On September 2, 2025, the La Conner Planning Commission convened to discuss significant issues surrounding the historic preservation district, particularly focusing on a proposed residential project that has sparked debate over siding materials and window designs. The meeting highlighted the tension between maintaining historical integrity and accommodating modern design preferences.

A key point of contention arose regarding the applicant's proposal to use vertical siding, which is explicitly prohibited in the historic preservation district according to the La Conner Municipal Code. The code mandates horizontal siding to preserve the architectural character of the area. Despite the applicant presenting examples of local buildings with vertical siding, the commission emphasized the importance of adhering to established guidelines to ensure consistency and historical accuracy.

Commission members expressed their views on the proposed horizontal windows, questioning whether they would align with the district's goals. One member noted that existing structures with horizontal windows complement the historical aesthetic, suggesting that the proposed design could be compatible with the neighborhood's character.

Public comments during the meeting reflected a mix of opinions. Some residents argued for flexibility in design, citing the evolving nature of the community and the need for modern interpretations of historical styles. Others stressed the importance of adhering strictly to the preservation code to maintain the district's historical significance.

The commission ultimately recognized the challenges of balancing historical preservation with contemporary needs. They discussed the necessity of clear definitions regarding what constitutes historical architecture, as well as the potential for modulating designs to fit within the preservation framework.

As the meeting concluded, the commission members were tasked with further deliberation on the application, weighing the recommendations from staff against community input. The outcome of this discussion will likely influence future projects within the historic preservation district, setting a precedent for how La Conner navigates the intersection of history and modernity in its architectural landscape.