HDRC Reviews Architectural Changes for Former Restaurant on Donaldson Avenue

The San Antonio Historic and Design Review Commission (HDRC) convened on September 3, 2025, to discuss a proposed renovation of a building previously used as a restaurant. The primary focus of the meeting was the owner's request to add a tower at the front entrance to enhance the building's visual appeal.

During the discussion, commissioners raised questions about the building's history and previous use. One commissioner inquired about the structure's past, suggesting it might have been a franchise establishment, such as Circle K or Napa Auto Parts. However, staff research did not yield conclusive evidence regarding the building's prior identity, with the earliest aerial photo dating back to 1966.

The applicant clarified that while they plan to add the tower, the existing awning would remain. They also intend to modify the window configurations, changing them to smaller, arched designs. Despite the applicant's intentions to improve the restaurant's attractiveness, several commissioners expressed concerns that the proposed changes contradicted established design guidelines.

Commissioner Sabino highlighted that the extensive alterations to the building's facade could undermine its historical integrity. In response, the applicant acknowledged the guidelines but emphasized their goal of making the front more appealing to customers.

After thorough discussion, a motion was made to proceed with the staff's recommendations regarding the application. The motion was approved unanimously, with several commissioners encouraging the applicant to consider a Design Review Committee (DRC) site visit to explore design options that would better align with the building's mid-century modern aesthetic.

The meeting concluded with a call for the next agenda item, indicating the HDRC's commitment to preserving the historical character of San Antonio while accommodating new developments.