Austin Commission Reviews Proposal for Multi-Unit Residence on Brownlee Circle

In a recent government meeting held on September 3, 2025, the Austin Historic Landmark Commission discussed a proposal for a multi-unit residence in the Old West Austin neighborhood. This proposal, which has been under consideration for three years, aims to construct a two-story building with three units on a site previously approved for demolition. The demolition site was deemed non-contributing to the historic district, allowing for this new development to be reviewed under the city’s historic design standards.

The meeting highlighted the ongoing efforts of property owners Melissa Skidmore and David Webber from Weber Studios, who presented their case for the new construction. They emphasized that the design of the building has remained unchanged over the years, and they have made adjustments to comply with city regulations. Notably, they have proposed adding a door to convert the structure into a four-unit residence to facilitate the permitting process.

Commissioners raised concerns regarding height restrictions related to a contested zoning covenant from 1950, which has been deemed unenforceable. The property owners clarified that their proposal meets all current zoning requirements and does not violate any historic preservation standards.

The discussion underscored the complexities of navigating historic preservation regulations while addressing the growing demand for housing in Austin. As the city grapples with housing shortages, the outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for future developments in historic districts, balancing the need for new housing with the preservation of Austin’s architectural heritage.

The commission is expected to continue reviewing the proposal, with further comments and discussions anticipated in upcoming meetings. The outcome will be closely watched by both developers and preservation advocates as Austin continues to evolve amidst its rich historical backdrop.