German Village Commission Approves Major Facade Alterations and Window Replacements

The Special Meeting of the German Village Commission held on September 3, 2025, focused on several requests for building alterations and renovations within the historic district. The meeting began with a review of a proposal to dismantle and rebuild 80% of the west elevation facade of a property, which includes replacing two sandstone rentals and all windows on the front elevation. The commission emphasized the need for detailed specifications regarding the window trim, mortar type, and decorative elements.

Staff conducted a site visit and reported that the six windows on the first and second floors were not original and showed signs of deterioration. The commission recommended approval for the replacement of all eight windows, contingent upon receiving a specification sheet for the proposed windows and further details on the wood trim and decorative elements.

The next item on the agenda involved a request for exterior alterations at 143 East Livingston Avenue, where the applicant proposed installing three fixed windows in original openings. The commission sought clarification on the window sizes and their alignment with original openings, citing security concerns as a reason for the proposed dimensions. The staff recommended approval, provided that the windows are restored to their original sizes.

Following this, the commission reviewed a request for alterations at 191 Jackson Street, which included landscaping and demolition of an existing deck. The proposal aimed to convert a window into a door and replace a picket fence. Concerns were raised regarding the design of the new decks and the height of the steps. The commission suggested continuing the application to allow the applicant time to refine the design.

Throughout the meeting, the commission members engaged in detailed discussions about the historical appropriateness of the proposed changes, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the architectural integrity of the German Village. The meeting concluded with a series of motions to approve the discussed alterations, contingent upon the fulfillment of specified conditions.

Overall, the commission's deliberations highlighted their commitment to preserving the historical character of the German Village while accommodating necessary renovations. The next steps involve the applicants addressing the commission's concerns and submitting the required documentation for final approvals.