The Oshkosh Common Council meeting on September 9, 2025, featured a passionate appeal from local residents regarding a proposed easement that could significantly impact their properties. The couple, who recently purchased their home on Somerset Way, expressed deep concerns about the implications of the easement, which would affect their garage, patio, and landscaping.

The residents highlighted that the easement would take up to 20% of their lot, severely limiting their use of the backyard and compromising their ability to maintain a fully fenced yard for their dog. They argued that the city has not provided alternative solutions, such as rerouting the storm sewer or creating a retention pond, which they believe would be less disruptive.

Additionally, the couple raised issues about the existing storm sewer, claiming it has been improperly draining onto their property for decades, potentially causing damage to their home’s foundation. They expressed frustration over the lack of city engagement, noting that only a few council members had visited their property to assess the situation before the plan commission recommended approval of the easement.

The couple called for the council to reconsider the easement, emphasizing the need for the city to protect private property rights and to explore other options that would not infringe on their home. They also mentioned the financial implications, arguing that the city's negligence in maintaining the storm sewer has led to an overvaluation of their property, resulting in higher taxes and insurance costs.

The discussion underscored the tension between municipal planning and individual property rights, raising questions about the city's responsibility to its residents and the need for thorough site evaluations before making significant decisions that affect homeowners. The council's next steps remain to be seen as they weigh the residents' concerns against the proposed infrastructure changes.