The City of Webster Groves Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) meeting on September 9, 2025, highlighted critical discussions regarding the preservation of the city’s historic homes and the challenges faced in protecting them from demolition. A significant point raised was the current ordinance requiring HPC approval for the demolition of homes over 50 years old. While some homes approved for demolition are in poor condition, many are still structurally sound and could be preserved with proper care and renovation.

Commission members expressed concern over the limited criteria for designating homes as historically significant, which currently hinges on their architectural value or historical importance to the community. This limitation means that many viable homes may be lost if they do not meet these specific criteria, even if they contribute to the community's character.

The discussion also touched on the broader implications of losing historic homes, with members noting that once these structures are gone, they cannot be replaced. The sentiment was clear: preserving the architectural heritage of Webster Groves is essential for maintaining the community's identity and history. The commission acknowledged the need for a more robust approach to protect homes that, while not officially designated as historic, still hold value for the community.

In addition to the preservation discussions, the meeting included updates from the historical society, including a recent article published about Lustron Homes and proposed bylaw changes aimed at increasing board member engagement. However, attendance at society events has been low, indicating a need for improved community involvement.

As the HPC continues its efforts, there is a growing interest in collaborating with local organizations, such as the Community Land Trust, to identify properties suitable for renovation and preservation. This partnership could enhance the city’s efforts to maintain its historical character while addressing community needs for housing.

The meeting underscored the importance of community engagement in preservation efforts, as members emphasized that the history and character of Webster Groves are not just about buildings but about the community's shared identity and heritage. The HPC aims to keep these discussions alive and encourage residents to participate in preserving the unique charm of their city.