In the heart of Brookline, Massachusetts, the Select Board convened on September 16, 2025, to address pressing issues surrounding public transportation and urban forestry. As the meeting unfolded, board members engaged in a passionate discussion about the balance between enhancing public transit and preserving the town's cherished trees.

The conversation was sparked by the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority's (MBTA) plans to expand the public transportation system, which would inevitably lead to the removal of several trees, including a notable Pin Oak. Board member Paul expressed deep concern for individuals with disabilities, recounting personal experiences that highlighted the challenges faced by those needing accessible public transport. He emphasized that while trees are vital to the community, the needs of people must take precedence. “You can replace a tree, but you can’t replace a person,” he stated, underscoring the urgency of improving accessibility for all residents.

Other board members echoed this sentiment, recognizing the importance of public transportation in reducing barriers for individuals with mobility issues. They noted that the impact of expanding transit options would far outweigh the environmental cost of losing a few trees. “The impact on the climate or of expanding public transportation is much larger,” one member remarked, reinforcing the idea that the project would ultimately benefit the community as a whole.

The board also acknowledged the MBTA's improved responsiveness during this public process, a shift that has not always been the case in past interactions. This newfound collaboration was seen as a positive step towards better communication and project management, which could lead to more effective outcomes for Brookline's residents.

As the meeting progressed, the board voted unanimously to affirm the decision of the tree planting committee, allowing the MBTA's plan to move forward. This decision reflects a broader commitment to enhancing public transportation while striving to mitigate the environmental impact through careful planning and community engagement.

In closing, the Select Board expressed gratitude for the hard work of the Department of Public Works and the urban forestry manager, recognizing the complexities involved in balancing community needs with environmental stewardship. The meeting concluded with a sense of optimism for the future, as Brookline continues to navigate the challenges of urban development while prioritizing the well-being of its residents.