In a tense special meeting held on September 18, 2025, the Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners grappled with a contentious issue: the potential condemnation of a private property on Fisher Island, valued at approximately $180 million. The urgency of the situation stemmed from an impending closing date for the property, which has been a topic of negotiation for several months.

As discussions unfolded, commissioners expressed their concerns about the procedural aspects of the meeting. Commissioner Cohen Hayes voiced unease over the lack of notice given to the property owner, emphasizing the importance of allowing them the opportunity to present their case before the board. "We can't say the size of government is too big and then come in and make a decision to condemn a private land owner's property," he stated, highlighting the ethical implications of such a move.

The board was presented with two motions: one advocating for negotiations with the property owner and the other proposing to proceed directly to eminent domain if negotiations failed. The legal team clarified that, by law, negotiations must occur before any condemnation can take place. However, the urgency of the situation raised questions about the effectiveness of the negotiation process, with some commissioners fearing that rushing into eminent domain could lead to costly legal battles.

Commissioner Regalado, who had added additional items to the discussion, underscored the necessity of acquiring the property to ensure the continued operation of Port Miami, which plays a crucial role in the local economy. "We want to protect a port that creates hundreds of thousands of jobs," he argued, framing the acquisition as a matter of public interest.

Despite the pressing need for a decision, several commissioners expressed discomfort with the rushed nature of the meeting and the lack of comprehensive information regarding the property owner’s position. "I do not want to be the reason that us purchasing this property in a year or in six months costs us another $100 million," one commissioner remarked, reflecting a shared concern about the financial implications of the board's actions.

As the meeting progressed, the board sought clarity on the differences between the two motions, aiming to find a path forward that would satisfy both legal requirements and community interests. The discussions highlighted the delicate balance between governmental authority and private property rights, a theme that resonated deeply within the context of Miami-Dade's rapidly evolving landscape.

The outcome of this meeting could have lasting implications for the future of Port Miami and the surrounding community, as the board navigates the complexities of property acquisition in a high-stakes environment. With the clock ticking on the closing date, the commissioners face a critical decision that will shape the economic landscape of Miami-Dade County for years to come.