The St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) convened on September 18, 2025, to discuss the installation of cellular antennas at Flagler College, a decision that could significantly impact both public safety and the preservation of historic architecture in the area.

The board's primary focus was on the necessity of additional cellular antennas, which some members questioned, citing a lack of evidence that current cellular service posed a public safety risk. A representative from the applicant's team clarified that the installation was not driven by safety concerns but rather by the increasing demand for reliable cellular service. They noted that calls are typically routed to the nearest available antenna, ensuring that emergency communications are maintained even during peak usage times.

Public comments highlighted concerns about potential damage to historic structures, with several speakers urging the board to prioritize preservation. Historian Leslie Keys emphasized the importance of safeguarding Flagler-era buildings from any adverse effects of the installation. Other community members echoed this sentiment, expressing worries about the visual impact of the antennas and the need for stringent oversight during and after installation.

In response to these concerns, the applicant assured the board that the installation would be minimally invasive, utilizing non-penetrating mounts and existing conduits to avoid damaging the historic fabric of the building. They also committed to removing any obsolete equipment in the future, addressing fears of abandoned technology cluttering the historic site.

The board members expressed a consensus on the need for modern technology while maintaining the integrity of St. Augustine's historic architecture. They discussed the importance of monitoring the installation process and ensuring compliance with the approved plans. Ultimately, the board moved towards a decision to approve the installation, contingent upon conditions that would safeguard the historic structure and ensure the removal of any outdated equipment.

This decision marks a significant step in balancing the needs of modern communication with the preservation of St. Augustine's rich historical heritage, reflecting the ongoing dialogue between progress and preservation in this iconic city.