During the Village of Waukesha Board of Review meeting on September 11, 2025, a homeowner raised concerns regarding the assessment of their property, highlighting significant issues that could impact its value. The resident, who lives on a street with 15 homes, described their property as a modest, single-story ranch with various maintenance needs, including an aging roof, crumbling garage floors, and outdated landscaping.

The homeowner expressed apprehension about the recent increase in property assessment, fearing that their home was being compared to more impressive neighboring properties. They questioned the methodology used for the assessment, particularly whether it involved a thorough evaluation beyond a simple drive-by inspection. The resident emphasized the importance of understanding how their home was appraised, especially given the presence of an environmental corridor on their land, which restricts development and could affect its marketability.

In their presentation, the homeowner referenced a 2016 appraisal, noting that they had paid significantly above this value when purchasing the property. They argued that the environmental corridor, which comprises approximately two acres of their total 3.47-acre lot, should be factored into the assessment, as it limits potential uses of the land. The resident also mentioned recent developments nearby that could further impact their property’s privacy and value.

The discussion highlighted broader concerns about property assessments in the village, particularly how they reflect the unique characteristics and limitations of individual homes. The Board of Review members engaged with the homeowner, seeking clarification on the details of the property and the assessment process.

As the meeting concluded, the homeowner's appeal underscored the complexities of property valuation in Waukesha, particularly in light of environmental considerations and market fluctuations. The Board's decision on the assessment will be closely watched by residents, as it may set a precedent for future evaluations in the community.