The Maui County Housing and Land Use Committee convened on September 24, 2025, to discuss critical issues surrounding affordable housing in the region. The meeting focused on the administration's approach to residential preferences and the ongoing challenges in providing affordable housing solutions.

The session began with a discussion on the importance of defining "affordable housing" and identifying the target demographic. A key point raised was the need for clarity on who benefits from affordable housing initiatives. Deputy Director of Housing responded positively, noting an upcoming meeting with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) that aims to provide further guidance on residential preferences. This meeting is expected to yield favorable insights, allowing the county to move forward with implementing these preferences.

Committee members emphasized the necessity of ensuring that policies are practical for administration. There was a consensus on the importance of transparency and fairness in managing the residential preference list, with calls for the administration to take a more active role rather than delegating responsibilities to developers.

Member Bolton highlighted the need to prioritize at-risk residents, particularly those in low-income brackets, as they are closest to experiencing homelessness. Bolton opposed any proposals that would shift resources from moderate-income housing to above-moderate housing, arguing that the focus should remain on helping those most in need.

The discussion also touched on the long-term affordability of housing. Bolton presented examples of significant price increases in local properties over the years, advocating for policies that extend affordability for future buyers. The committee recognized the urgency of addressing shelter needs, with members expressing a desire to ensure that affordable housing policies effectively support residents seeking stable living conditions.

Additionally, the committee reviewed the status of existing housing credits and projects, including those affected by recent wildfires. The Deputy Director confirmed that while some projects were lost, others remain operational, and the county continues to explore options for purchasing properties to manage through community land trusts.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the complexities of affordable housing in Maui County, with a clear call for collaboration between policymakers and administrators to create effective, transparent, and equitable housing solutions. The committee plans to continue these discussions in future meetings, focusing on actionable steps to address the pressing housing crisis.