The Town Council of St. John, Indiana, convened on September 24, 2025, to discuss pressing issues affecting the community, particularly the proposed annexation of land for a large housing development. The meeting highlighted significant concerns from residents regarding the potential impact of this development on local infrastructure, water resources, and overall community character.

One of the most contentious topics was Ordinance 18-70, which proposes the annexation of 168 acres to accommodate nearly 1,000 new homes. Council members expressed their apprehensions about the density of the proposed development, with some likening it to "putting 5 pounds of poop in a half-pound bag." Residents echoed these sentiments during public comments, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach to housing that includes a variety of options rather than a singular focus on high-density developments.

Concerns were raised about the adequacy of the town's water supply to support such a significant increase in population. The council discussed the implications of Senate Enrolled Act 1, which is expected to affect property tax revenues and necessitate a shift in funding strategies. The town's financial advisors indicated that while current budgets are sustainable, future planning is crucial to address potential revenue declines starting in 2028.

Public comments revealed a strong sentiment against the proposed development, with residents expressing fears about the strain on local resources, including roads, schools, and water supply. Many voiced their frustrations over a perceived lack of transparency and communication from the council regarding the development process and its implications.

In response to the overwhelming public opposition, council members acknowledged the need for further discussion and consideration of the community's concerns. A workshop is planned for later this year to delve deeper into the financial impacts of the proposed annexation and to explore alternative solutions that align with the community's needs.

As the council moves forward, the focus will remain on balancing growth with the preservation of St. John's character and ensuring that infrastructure can adequately support any new developments. The next steps will involve continued dialogue with residents and careful evaluation of the proposed housing project to ensure it serves the best interests of the community.