The Design Review Board of Laguna Beach convened on September 25, 2025, to discuss the potential historic significance of a property linked to the original 40-acre land grant awarded to William F. Egan in 1910. The existing residence, constructed between 1909 and 1928, is noted as possibly the oldest house in South Laguna and the last remaining homestead house in the city.

During the meeting, the board reviewed assessments from two historic consultants regarding the property’s eligibility for listing on the National Register of Historic Places and the California Register of Historic Places. While one consultant deemed the property significant under California criteria, the other found it ineligible. To resolve the discrepancy, the city sought an independent evaluation from GPA Consultants, who concluded that the property does not meet the criteria for historic resource status under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) or the city’s preservation ordinance.

Despite the findings, city staff expressed support for the project, emphasizing that required findings could be made. However, they urged the board to deliberate on privacy, view equity, and historic preservation matters before making a final decision. The board was tasked with determining whether the property qualifies as a historic resource under CEQA.

As the meeting progressed, the board opened the public hearing, allowing stakeholders to voice their opinions on the project. The outcome of this deliberation will have significant implications for the property’s future and its role in Laguna Beach's historical narrative. The board is expected to adopt a resolution approving the design review and coastal development permit, contingent on their findings regarding the historic status of the property.