The October Borough Council Workshop Meeting in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, held on October 2, 2025, focused on significant discussions regarding local law enforcement practices and community trust. A key topic was the Carlisle Police Department's recent interaction with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) concerning an undocumented juvenile. Chief Landis clarified that while the department does not typically engage with ICE, they sought assistance in this instance due to the inability to release the juvenile to a relative. This incident has prompted the department to review its policies and ensure that future interactions with federal agencies are communicated with command staff.

During the meeting, community members expressed their views on a proposed resolution aimed at establishing Carlisle as a "welcoming community." Some residents voiced strong opposition, arguing that such a designation could hinder law enforcement's ability to uphold federal laws. Marvin Salzman, a local resident, emphasized the importance of enforcing federal regulations while maintaining the town's welcoming spirit. In contrast, John Werner, who initially proposed the ordinance, argued that it would allow local law enforcement to focus on justice without the complications of immigration status.

The council encouraged public participation, allowing residents to voice their opinions on the proposed ordinance. The discussions highlighted the ongoing tension between community values and law enforcement practices, with the council planning to revisit the topic in future meetings. The outcome of these discussions will be crucial in shaping the relationship between the Carlisle Police Department and the community it serves.